Using the Improved Remove Tool in Photoshop 2024

Download the PDF: Using the Improved Remove Tool

Written by Steve Patterson.

Photoshop’s Remove Tool, first introduced in Photoshop 2023, uses AI and machine learning to instantly remove people, objects or distractions from photos just by painting over them. And now in Photoshop 2024, the Remove Tool is even easier to use thanks to a couple of great new features.

What’s new with the Remove Tool in Photoshop 2024?

• The Remove Tool can now remove people or objects just by dragging an outline around them, so there’s no need to paint over the entire area.
• The Remove Tool now includes a Subtract mode so you can subtract areas you may have painted over by mistake before removing them. I cover both of these new features in this tutorial.

Which Photoshop version do I need?

You’ll need Photoshop 2024 to use the Remove Tool’s new features.

If you already have a Creative Cloud subscription, make sure that your copy of Photoshop is up to date.

Let’s get started!

Download this tutorial as a print-ready PDF!

The document setup

To show how the Remove Tool works, I’ll use this image from Adobe Stock and I’ll use the Remove Tool to remove the empty chair and bag on the left.

The original photo.

See also:

Where to find the Remove Tool

The Remove Tool is still found in the same spot in Photoshop’s toolbar, nested in with the Spot Healing Brush and the other healing tools.

If a tool other than the Remove Tool is visible in that spot, click and hold on the tool’s icon and choose the Remove Tool from the fly-out menu.

Selecting the Remove Tool from the toolbar.

The Sample all layers and Remove after each stroke options

With the Remove Tool active, go up to the Options Bar and you’ll find the same Sample all layers and Remove after each stroke options from Photoshop 2023.

• Sample all layers lets you work on a separate layer so you can remove objects without making permanent changes to the original photo.
• Remove after each stroke tells Photoshop to remove the person or object you highlighted with the Remove Tool as soon as you release your mouse button.

The Sample all layers and Remove after each stroke options in the Options Bar.

New! The Add to and Subtract from brushed area options

Also in the Options Bar (and new in Photoshop 2024) are the Add to brushed area and Subtract from brushed area options.

In Photoshop 2023, the Remove Tool was always in Add to brushed area mode. But 2024 now includes the option to subtract areas we may have highlighted by mistake before Photoshop removes them. We’ll see how that works in a moment.

The new Add to brushed area (left) and Subtract from brushed area (right) options.

Tip: Always use the Remove Tool on a separate layer

When using the Remove Tool, you should always work on a separate layer to avoid making permanent changes to your image.

So before I remove anything, I’ll first go to the Layers panel and click the Add New Layer icon.

Adding a new blank layer to ue with the Remove Tool.

Photoshop adds a new blank layer above the image on the Background layer.

The new layer is added.

We also need to turn on Sample all layers in the Options Bar. For some reason Adobe turns it off by default.

Turning on Sample all layers.

And for now, I’ll leave Remove after each stroke turned on as well. But we will need to turn it off to use the new Subtract mode, as we’ll see in a moment.

Remove after each stroke is turned on by default.

New! Outline an object with the Remove Tool to highlight it

Back in Photoshop 2023, we needed to paint with the Remove Tool over the entire object we wanted to remove. Depending on the size and shape of the object, this could take some time.

Here I’ve painted over the entire chair and bag, plus the shadows in the sand. The areas where I painted are highlighted in magenta.

Tip: You can adjust the size of the Remove Tool brush using the left and right bracket keys ( [ and ] ) on your keyboard.

Painting with the Remove Tool over everything I want to remove.

But now in Photoshop 2024, there’s no need to paint over the entire area. We can simply paint an outline around the object we want to remove. Photoshop will then highlight everything inside the outline when you release your mouse button.

So I’ll drag an outline around the chair, the bag and the shadows.

Painting an outline around the objects with the Remove Tool.

I’ll release my mouse button, and Photoshop highlights everything inside the outline.

The area inside the outline is highlighted.

Then after a few seconds, because I have Remove after each stroke turned on in the Options Bar, Photoshop removes the chair, the bag and the shadows from the photo and replaces them with new AI-generated content that matches the surrounding area.

The Remove Tool fills the area with AI-generated content.

Cleaning up artifacts with the Remove Tool

Even though the Remove Tool uses AI and machine learning, it’s not as powerful as Generative Fill and can sometimes add weird artifacts or repeating textures. So you may need to paint over some areas again with the Remove Tool to clean them up.

Here we see an obvious example of repeating textures in the sand.

Repeating textures created by the Remove Tool.

So I’ll just paint over that area again.

Using the Remove Tool to clean up its own mistakes.

And when I release my mouse button, the problem is gone.

Tip: You may need to paint over an area multiple times with the Remove Tool to get a good result. Painting with a smaller brush or over smaller areas at a time can also help.

The repeating textures are gone.

The Remove Tool removed the objects non-destructively

By working on a separate layer above the photo (and with Sample all layers turned on in the Options Bar), the objects were removed non-destructively.

I can toggle the layer off by clicking its visibility icon.

Turning the top layer off.

And the objects return in the photo.

The removed objects remain in the original photo.

New! The Subtract from brushed area option

Back in Photoshop 2023, a frustrating issue with the Remove Tool was that if you painted over something by mistake, there was no way to subtract it from the highlighted area before Photoshop removed it.

But now in Photoshop 2024, the Remove Tool includes a Subtract from brushed area option in the Options Bar, located next to the Add to brushed area option (also new) which is turned on by default.

The new Add to brushed area (left) and Subtract from brushed area (right) options.

For the Subtract option to work, we first need to turn off Remove after each stroke. If you leave it on, Photoshop will remove everything you painted over as soon as you release your mouse button, which means you won’t have time to subtract anything.

Remove after each stroke must be off to use Subtract mode.

To see how Subtract mode works, here I’ve painted over part of the woman’s feet and her chair which I don’t want to remove.

Accidentally painting over an area that should not be removed.

One way (which I don’t recommend) to switch to Subtract mode is to select the Subtract from brushed area option in the Options Bar.

Clicking the Subtract from brushed area icon.

But the reason I don’t recommend it is that the option in the Options Bar is sticky, meaning that it will remain selected (and the Remove Tool will remain in Subtract mode) until you go back to the Options Bar and reselect the Add to brushed area option.

A better way is to switch to Subtract mode temporarily by holding down the Alt key on a Windows PC or the Option key on a Mac.

With the key held down, the icon in the center of the brush cursor will change from a + sign to a – sign, letting you know you’re in Subtract mode.

Then simply paint back over areas to subtract them from the selection.

Hold Alt (Win) / Option (Mac) and paint over areas to subtract them.

While I’m here, I’m also going to subtract some of the highlighted areas within my chair selection where the sand and the water are showing through, just to keep as much of the original detail as possible. This can help the Remove Tool do a better job.

Subtracting areas to keep more of the original image detail.

Since Remove after each stroke is turned off, Photoshop won’t automatically remove the objects when you release your mouse button. Instead you need to click the check mark in the Options Bar.

Clicking the check mark to remove the objects.

And once again the chair, the bag and the shadows are removed, with new AI-generated content added in their place.

The final Remove Tool result.

And there we have it! That’s how to use the Remove Tool and its new features in Photoshop 2024 to quickly remove people, objects or distractions from your photos.

Related tutorials:

Don’t forget, all of my Photoshop tutorials are now available to download as PDFs!